Responsibility and Culpability in War

Peer-reviewed Journal Article

Ingierd, Helene Christiansen; & Syse, Henrik (2005) Responsibility and Culpability in War , Journal of Military Ethics 4(2): 85–99.

Abstract: This article furnishes a philosophical background for the current debate about responsibility and culpability for war crimes by referring to ideas from three important just war thinkers: Augustine, Francisco de Vitoria, and Michael Walzer. It combines lessons from these three thinkers with perspectives on current problems in the ethics of war, distinguishes between legal culpability, moral culpability, and moral responsibility, and stresses that even lower-ranking soldiers must in many cases assume moral responsibility for their acts, even though they are part of a military hierarchy and act under orders. The questions addressed in this article are arguably among the hardest and most muddled in military ethics and deserve close philosophical analysis and scrutiny.


Henrik Syse

Henrik Syse

Research Professor. Editor, Journal of Military Ethics