In this edited volume Karin Aggestam and the various authors paint a bleak picture of the state of affairs for Israeli and Palestinian democracy, dialogue attempts and the peace process. Unsurprisingly, it does not leave much space for hope. As Anders Persson demonstrates, all democracy measuring bodies have shown Israel – and the Palestinians – undergoing a steep decline in democracy measurements. Lisa Strömbom shows how initiatives that try to tell both sides of the story have become so marginal that they are essentially preaching to the choir. Lior Lehrs shows how even the unambitious attempt to ‘shrink the conflict’ has failed. Illustratingly, Isabell Schierenbeck demonstrates how the protest movement against the judicial overhaul in Israel was unable – and unwilling – to include the anti-occupation movement in their demonstrations. While it is evident that the authors have no illusions about the negative spiral on all fronts, I am still left with the sense that some of the chapters are stuck in debates that seem dated. For instance, the various datasets that show a negative trend in Israeli democracy are still based on the premise that after sixty years and a complete infrastructural integration of the territories, the occupation is still treated as an externality to the state. Aggestam captures this problem clearly when she writes in the concluding chapter that ‘democratic backsliding … is deeply rooted in the definition of who constitutes the demos.’ (p. 128) A similar and even more disparaging sense comes to mind when reading about potential future negotiations at a time when the Gaza ceasefire has crossed the Uppsala Conflict Data threshold for a full-scale war – 1000 deaths per year.